| 2000-02-19 | Witton Albion v Farsley Celtic | 2-3 | | 1999-00 | ANANE, GRAYSTONE |
| 2000-02-12 | Ashton United v Witton Albion | 2-2 | | 1999-00 | GLEGHORN, HENNIN |
| 2000-02-05 | Lincoln United v Witton Albion | 1-2 | | 1999-00 | WEST, GRAYSTONE |
| 2000-01-29 | Witton Albion v Netherfield Kendal | 2-1 | | 1999-00 | ANANE, BOYD |
| 2000-01-22 | Harrogate Town v Witton Albion | 1-1 | | 1999-00 | HENNIN |
| 2000-01-15 | Witton Albion v Northwich Victoria | 2-2 | MCSC S/F | 1999-00 | GRAYSTONE, BISHOP (p) |
| 2000-01-08 | Burscough v Witton Albion | 1-1 | | 1999-00 | ANANE |
| 2000-01-03 | Gretna v Witton Albion | 0-3 | | 1999-00 | GLEGHORN, ANANE, HAW |
| 1999-12-27 | Witton Albion v Congleton Town | 5-3 | | 1999-00 | HENNIN, HENNIN, HENNIN, ANANE, HAW |
| 1999-12-18 | Witton Albion v Lincoln United | 3-1 | | 1999-00 | ANANE, ANANE, HAW (p) |
| 1999-12-14 | Accrington Stanley v Witton Albion | 0-0 | | 1999-00 | |
| 1999-12-04 | Witton Albion v Matlock Town | 1-1 | | 1999-00 | COX |
| 1999-11-27 | Blyth Spartans v Witton Albion | 2-0 | FAT 2 | 1999-00 | |
| 1999-11-23 | Witton Albion v Burscough | 1-1 | | 1999-00 | GLEGHORN |
| 1999-11-20 | Stocksbridge Park Steels v Witton Albion | 1-2 | | 1999-00 | GLEGHORN, HENNIN |
| 1999-11-12 | Witton Albion v Gretna | 6-1 | | 1999-00 | HENNIN, HENNIN, HAW, HAW, CARTER, ANANE |
| 1999-11-06 | Matlock Town v Witton Albion | 2-2 | | 1999-00 | BOYD, CARTER (p) |
| 1999-10-30 | Witton Albion v Ossett Town | 3-2 | | 1999-00 | GLEGHORN, GLEGHORN, GRAYSTONE |
| 1999-10-26 | Trafford v Witton Albion | 1-1 | | 1999-00 | BOYD |
| 1999-10-23 | Farsley Celtic v Witton Albion | 1-0 | | 1999-00 | |
| 1999-10-19 | Witton Albion v Ashton United | 3-2 | | 1999-00 | ANANE, ANANE, GLEGHORN |
| 1999-10-16 | Whitley Bay v Witton Albion | 2-4 | | 1999-00 | GLEGHORN, GLEGHORN, ANANE, Hetherington (og) |
| 1999-10-09 | Witton Albion v Workington | 2-2 | | 1999-00 | CARTER, GLEGHORN |
| 1999-10-05 | Witton Albion v Runcorn | 2-2 | LC Group | 1999-00 | GLEGHORN, GLEGHORN |
| 1999-10-02 | Netherfield Kendal v Witton Albion | 0-4 | | 1999-00 | HENNIN, HENNIN, ANANE, ANANE |
| 1999-09-28 | Colwyn Bay v Witton Albion | 5-2 | LC Group | 1999-00 | CARTER, CARTER (p) |
| 1999-09-25 | Witton Albion v Trafford | 2-0 | | 1999-00 | HENNIN, COX |
| 1999-09-18 | Witton Albion v Whitley Bay | 2-0 | | 1999-00 | HENNIN, HENSHAW |
| 1999-09-14 | Flixton v Witton Albion | 0-1 | | 1999-00 | BISHOP (p) |
| 1999-09-11 | Witton Albion v Harrogate Town | 3-1 | | 1999-00 | BOYD, HENNIN, ANANE |
| 1999-09-04 | Workington v Witton Albion | 1-1 | | 1999-00 | GLEGHORN |
| 1999-08-30 | Congleton Town v Witton Albion | 0-1 | | 1999-00 | HENNIN |
| 1999-08-28 | Witton Albion v Bradford Park Avenue | 0-2 | | 1999-00 | |
| 1999-08-24 | Witton Albion v Vauxhall Motors | 1-2 | CSC Pr. | 1999-00 | ANANE |
| 1999-08-21 | North Ferriby United v Witton Albion | 1-0 | FAC Pr. | 1999-00 | |
| 1999-08-17 | Chorley v Witton Albion | 2-5 | | 1999-00 | COX, COX, HENNIN, ANANE, Hill (og) |
| 1999-08-14 | Witton Albion v Stocksbridge Park Steels | 1-1 | | 1999-00 | HENNIN |
| 1999-05-01 | Alfreton Town v Witton Albion | 1-3 | | 1998-99 | ANDERSON, BISHOP (p), CARTER |
| 1999-04-27 | Witton Albion v Gretna | 5-1 | | 1998-99 | CARTER, CARTER, BISHOP, BISHOP, GLEGHORN |
| 1999-04-24 | Lincoln United v Witton Albion | 3-1 | | 1998-99 | ANANE |
| 1999-04-22 | Stocksbridge Park Steels v Witton Albion | 2-1 | | 1998-99 | BOYD |
| 1999-04-13 | Trafford v Witton Albion | 1-1 | | 1998-99 | ANDERSON |
| 1999-04-10 | Witton Albion v Hucknall Town | 0-2 | | 1998-99 | |
| 1999-04-07 | Hucknall Town v Witton Albion | 0-1 | | 1998-99 | GLEGHORN |
| 1999-04-05 | Witton Albion v Netherfield Kendal | 1-0 | | 1998-99 | GLEGHORN |
| 1999-04-03 | Bradford Park Avenue v Witton Albion | 5-0 | | 1998-99 | |
| 1999-04-01 | Witton Albion v Northwich Victoria | 0-2 | MCSC S/F | 1998-99 | |
| 1999-03-30 | Witton Albion v Droylsden | 0-2 | | 1998-99 | |
| 1999-03-27 | Witton Albion v Alfreton Town | 4-0 | | 1998-99 | COMLEY, CARTER, GLEGHORN |
| 1999-03-23 | Flixton v Witton Albion | 2-3 | | 1998-99 | COMLEY, COX, LLOYD |
