| 1996-05-04 | Bamber Bridge v Witton Albion | 1-1 | | 1995-96 | WATSON |
| 1996-05-01 | Winsford United v Witton Albion | 1-2 | MCSC F. | 1995-96 | WATSON, WATSON (p) |
| 1996-04-29 | Winsford United v Witton Albion | 2-1 | | 1995-96 | McDONALD |
| 1996-04-27 | Witton Albion v Buxton | 1-3 | | 1995-96 | WATSON |
| 1996-04-20 | Gainsborough Trinity v Witton Albion | 1-0 | | 1995-96 | |
| 1996-04-15 | Hyde United v Witton Albion | 1-0 | | 1995-96 | |
| 1996-04-08 | Witton Albion v Winsford United | 2-0 | | 1995-96 | WATSON, WATSON |
| 1996-04-06 | Droylsden v Witton Albion | 2-1 | | 1995-96 | HORSFIELD |
| 1996-03-30 | Witton Albion v Boston United | 1-1 | | 1995-96 | WATSON |
| 1996-03-23 | Knowsley United v Witton Albion | 2-2 | | 1995-96 | McDONALD, WATSON (p) |
| 1996-03-19 | Matlock Town v Witton Albion | 5-2 | | 1995-96 | HORSFIELD, WHALLEY |
| 1996-03-16 | Witton Albion v Hyde United | 1-1 | | 1995-96 | WATSON |
| 1996-03-12 | Altrincham v Witton Albion | 1-2 | CSC S/F -2 | 1995-96 | McDONALD, McDONALD |
| 1996-03-09 | Blyth Spartans v Witton Albion | 2-0 | | 1995-96 | |
| 1996-03-05 | Gainsborough Trinity v Witton Albion | 3-2 | LC 4 | 1995-96 | WATSON, WATSON |
| 1996-03-02 | Witton Albion v Barrow | 1-0 | | 1995-96 | McNEILIS |
| 1996-02-27 | Witton Albion v Northwich Victoria | 3-2 | MCSC S/F | 1995-96 | COWLEY, COWLEY (p), HORSFIELD |
| 1996-02-24 | Witton Albion v Droylsden | 2-1 | | 1995-96 | McNEILIS, HORSFIELD |
| 1996-02-20 | Witton Albion v Altrincham | 1-1 | CSC S/F -1 | 1995-96 | WATSON (p) |
| 1996-02-17 | Marine v Witton Albion | 2-1 | | 1995-96 | TAYLOR |
| 1996-02-10 | Witton Albion v Marine | 2-0 | | 1995-96 | WATSON, WHALLEY |
| 1996-01-13 | Witton Albion v Bishop Auckland | 1-2 | | 1995-96 | BRENCHLEY |
| 1996-01-09 | Marine v Witton Albion | 2-0 | NPL Presidents's Cup 1 | 1995-96 | |
| 1996-01-06 | Guiseley v Witton Albion | 0-1 | | 1995-96 | TAYLOR |
| 1996-01-01 | Witton Albion v Leek Town | 2-1 | | 1995-96 | WATSON, HORSFIELD |
| 1995-12-19 | Atherton Laburnum Rovers v Witton Albion | 2-5 | LC 3 | 1995-96 | WATSON, WATSON, WATSON, WATSON (p), JONES |
| 1995-12-16 | Accrington Stanley v Witton Albion | 1-2 | | 1995-96 | BRENCHLEY, B (p) |
| 1995-12-09 | Witton Albion v Spennymoor United | 2-2 | | 1995-96 | WATSON, WATSON (p) |
| 1995-12-04 | Bishop Auckland v Witton Albion | 3-1 | FAT 3q. 2nd Rep. | 1995-96 | WATSON (p) |
| 1995-12-02 | Frickley Athletic v Witton Albion | 1-1 | | 1995-96 | WATSON |
| 1995-11-28 | Witton Albion v Bishop Auckland | 0-0 | FAT 3q. Rep. | 1995-96 | |
| 1995-11-25 | Bishop Auckland v Witton Albion | 0-0 | FAT 3q. | 1995-96 | |
| 1995-11-21 | Witton Albion v Northwich Victoria | 2-0 | CSC 3 | 1995-96 | MACAULEY, COWLEY |
| 1995-11-18 | Witton Albion v Emley | 3-1 | | 1995-96 | WATSON, COWLEY, McNEILIS |
| 1995-11-11 | Telford United v Witton Albion | 2-1 | FAC 1 | 1995-96 | WATSON |
| 1995-11-04 | Bishop Auckland v Witton Albion | 1-2 | | 1995-96 | WATSON, McNEILIS |
| 1995-11-01 | Leigh Rmi v Witton Albion | 0-3 | LC 2 Rep. | 1995-96 | MACAULEY, WATSON, D (p) |
| 1995-10-28 | Witton Albion v Gainsborough Trinity | 0-2 | | 1995-96 | |
| 1995-10-24 | Witton Albion v Leigh Rmi | 2-2 | LC 2 | 1995-96 | CAMDEN, CAMDEN (p) |
| 1995-10-21 | Witton Albion v Morecambe | 3-2 | FAC 4q. | 1995-96 | WATSON, WATSON, COWLEY |
| 1995-10-17 | Barrow v Witton Albion | 3-0 | | 1995-96 | |
| 1995-10-14 | Witton Albion v Blyth Spartans | 2-1 | | 1995-96 | CAMDEN, CAMDEN (p) |
| 1995-10-10 | Spennymoor United v Witton Albion | 3-1 | | 1995-96 | THOMAS |
| 1995-10-07 | Chorley v Witton Albion | 4-0 | | 1995-96 | |
| 1995-10-04 | Witton Albion v Chorley | 2-1 | | 1995-96 | THOMAS, CAMDEN |
| 1995-09-30 | Witton Albion v Guiseley | 3-2 | | 1995-96 | THOMAS, CAMDEN, RODWELL |
| 1995-09-26 | Colwyn Bay v Witton Albion | 1-1 | | 1995-96 | ROSE |
| 1995-09-23 | Witton Albion v Knowsley United | 2-1 | | 1995-96 | THOMAS, CAMDEN |
| 1995-09-19 | Witton Albion v Matlock Town | 3-2 | | 1995-96 | THOMAS, THOMAS, THOMAS (p) |
| 1995-09-16 | Emley v Witton Albion | 1-0 | | 1995-96 | |
