| 1986-09-27 | South Liverpool v Witton Albion | 3-1 | | 1986-87 | DULLAGHAN |
| 1986-09-23 | Witton Albion v Chorley | 2-3 | | 1986-87 | DULLAGHAN, McMAHON (p) |
| 1986-09-20 | Witton Albion v Barrow | 2-3 | | 1986-87 | PETERS (p), HORTON (p) |
| 1986-09-17 | Caernarfon Town v Witton Albion | 2-0 | | 1986-87 | |
| 1986-09-13 | Witton Albion v Hednesford Town | 0-2 | FAC 1q. | 1986-87 | |
| 1986-09-09 | Witton Albion v Workington | 3-1 | | 1986-87 | HORTON, McMAHON, WAGSTAFFE |
| 1986-09-06 | Southport v Witton Albion | 4-2 | | 1986-87 | HORTON, PETERS (p) |
| 1986-09-02 | Marine v Witton Albion | 3-1 | | 1986-87 | FARRELL |
| 1986-08-30 | Witton Albion v Gainsborough Trinity | 2-1 | | 1986-87 | HORTON, WAGSTAFFE |
| 1986-08-25 | Witton Albion v South Liverpool | 0-2 | | 1986-87 | |
| 1986-08-23 | Buxton v Witton Albion | 0-0 | | 1986-87 | |
| 1986-08-20 | Bangor City v Witton Albion | 3-1 | | 1986-87 | McMAHON |
| 1986-08-16 | Witton Albion v Goole Town | 2-1 | | 1986-87 | WAGSTAFFE, FARRELL |
| 1986-04-30 | Chorley v Witton Albion | 1-1 | LFT F. | 1985-86 | HORTON |
| 1986-04-28 | Witton Albion v South Liverpool | 1-1 | | 1985-86 | PHILLIPS (p) |
| 1986-04-26 | Chorley v Witton Albion | 0-0 | | 1985-86 | |
| 1986-04-24 | Stalybridge Celtic v Witton Albion | 1-3 | LFT S/F | 1985-86 | WAGSTAFFE, PHILLIPS (p), MEGRAM |
| 1986-04-22 | Witton Albion v Southport | 1-1 | | 1985-86 | HEATHCOTE (p) |
| 1986-04-19 | Witton Albion v Gainsborough Trinity | 1-2 | | 1985-86 | WAGSTAFFE |
| 1986-04-12 | Rhyl v Witton Albion | 2-4 | | 1985-86 | WAGSTAFFE, WAGSTAFFE, MEGRAM, HAWKINS |
| 1986-04-07 | Witton Albion v South Liverpool | 2-0 | LFT | 1985-86 | WAGSTAFFE, WAGSTAFFE |
| 1986-04-05 | Hyde United v Witton Albion | 2-2 | | 1985-86 | HORTON, HEATHCOTE |
| 1986-04-02 | Marine v Witton Albion | 3-1 | | 1985-86 | HEATHCOTE |
| 1986-03-31 | Macclesfield Town v Witton Albion | 1-1 | | 1985-86 | HORTON |
| 1986-03-29 | Witton Albion v Oswestry Town | 3-1 | | 1985-86 | HORTON, HORTON, FARRELL |
| 1986-03-25 | Goole Town v Witton Albion | 1-1 | | 1985-86 | PENNELL (p) |
| 1986-03-22 | Horwich R.M.I. v Witton Albion | 0-1 | | 1985-86 | HEATHCOTE (p) |
| 1986-03-19 | Witton Albion v Hyde United | 3-2 | | 1985-86 | WAGSTAFFE, WAGSTAFFE, HORTON |
| 1986-03-17 | Runcorn v Witton Albion | 1-1 | CSC S/F -2 | 1985-86 | BRADLEY |
| 1986-03-15 | Morecambe v Witton Albion | 4-1 | | 1985-86 | HEATHCOTE |
| 1986-03-12 | Witton Albion v Burton Albion | 1-1 | | 1985-86 | HEATHCOTE (p) |
| 1986-03-08 | Witton Albion v Runcorn | 0-1 | CSC S/F -1 | 1985-86 | |
| 1986-03-01 | Witton Albion v Buxton | 1-1 | | 1985-86 | WAGSTAFFE |
| 1986-02-22 | Witton Albion v Hyde United | 1-2 | LC 3 | 1985-86 | WAGSTAFFE |
| 1986-02-18 | Witton Albion v Ellesmere Port & Neston | 2-0 | LFT | 1985-86 | CROSS, NEEDHAM |
| 1986-02-15 | Witton Albion v Hyde United | 3-0 | CSC 2 | 1985-86 | FARRELL, FARRELL, HEATHCOTE |
| 1986-02-08 | Witton Albion v Worksop Town | 1-0 | | 1985-86 | HEATHCOTE (p) |
| 1986-02-04 | Witton Albion v Mossley | 2-1 | LC 2 Rep. | 1985-86 | FARRELL, PHILLIPS (p) |
| 1986-02-01 | Mossley v Witton Albion | 0-0 | LC 2 | 1985-86 | |
| 1986-01-28 | Witton Albion v Skelmersdale United | 1-0 | LFT | 1985-86 | WAGSTAFFE |
| 1986-01-25 | Witton Albion v Vauxhall | 3-1 | CSC 1 | 1985-86 | WAGSTAFFE, KILDUFF, HEATHCOTE |
| 1986-01-18 | Caernarfon Town v Witton Albion | 0-0 | | 1985-86 | |
| 1986-01-14 | Ellesmere Port & Neston v Witton Albion | 0-0 | LFT | 1985-86 | |
| 1986-01-11 | Witton Albion v Matlock Town | 1-1 | | 1985-86 | FARRELL |
| 1986-01-01 | Burton Albion v Witton Albion | 3-2 | | 1985-86 | BUXTON, KILDUFF |
| 1985-12-26 | Witton Albion v Macclesfield Town | 3-2 | | 1985-86 | BUXTON, BUXTON, BRADLEY |
| 1985-12-17 | South Liverpool v Witton Albion | 2-2 | LFT | 1985-86 | FARRELL, WAGSTAFFE |
| 1985-12-14 | Horwich R.M.I. v Witton Albion | 1-1 | PC1 -2 | 1985-86 | DAVISON |
| 1985-12-10 | Skelmersdale United v Witton Albion | 1-3 | LFT | 1985-86 | HAWKINS, HAWKINS, HAWKINS |
| 1985-12-07 | Witton Albion v Horwich R.M.I. | 1-4 | | 1985-86 | HOWARD |
