| 1958-03-08 | Witton Albion v Stockport County Reserves | 4-1 | | 1957-58 | STEPHENSON, STEPHENSON, WALLWORK, TAPLEY (p) |
| 1958-03-01 | Hyde United v Witton Albion | 2-0 | | 1957-58 | |
| 1958-02-22 | Stafford Rangers v Witton Albion | 4-5 | | 1957-58 | WALLWORK, WALLWORK, HACKETT, STEPHENSON (p), TAPLEY (p) |
| 1958-02-15 | Witton Albion v Port Vale Reserves | 3-0 | | 1957-58 | WALLWORK, WALLWORK, DORSETT |
| 1958-02-08 | Witton Albion v Bangor City | 4-0 | | 1957-58 | TAPLEY, TAPLEY, DORSETT, STEPHENSON (p) |
| 1958-02-01 | Witton Albion v Stockport County Reserves | 1-2 | CSC 1 | 1957-58 | DORSETT |
| 1958-01-25 | Altrincham v Witton Albion | 0-2 | | 1957-58 | DORSETT, McCANN |
| 1958-01-18 | Macclesfield Town v Witton Albion | 5-0 | | 1957-58 | |
| 1958-01-11 | Witton Albion v Stafford Rangers | 2-2 | | 1957-58 | DORSETT, Antonio (og) |
| 1958-01-04 | Rhyl v Witton Albion | 7-5 | | 1957-58 | WAINWRIGHT, WAINWRIGHT, DORSETT, DORSETT, HACKETT |
| 1958-01-01 | Buxton v Witton Albion | 7-1 | | 1957-58 | WAINWRIGHT |
| 1957-12-28 | Witton Albion v Chester Reserves | 3-3 | | 1957-58 | TAPLEY, TAPLEY, ASHLEY |
| 1957-12-26 | Witton Albion v Tranmere Rovers Reserves | 4-1 | | 1957-58 | DORSETT, DORSETT, ASHLEY, STEPHENSON (p) |
| 1957-12-25 | Northwich Victoria v Witton Albion | 3-1 | | 1957-58 | DORSETT |
| 1957-12-21 | Witton Albion v Crewe Alexandra Reserves | 2-0 | | 1957-58 | BARNES, Mountford (og) |
| 1957-12-14 | Stalybridge Celtic v Witton Albion | 0-2 | | 1957-58 | HAMBLETT, HACKETT |
| 1957-12-07 | Witton Albion v Hyde United | 2-4 | | 1957-58 | DALE, BARNES (p) |
| 1957-11-30 | Wellington Town v Witton Albion | 3-2 | | 1957-58 | ASHLEY, TAPLEY (p) |
| 1957-11-23 | Witton Albion v Rhyl | 3-0 | | 1957-58 | HAMBLETT, HAMBLETT, DORSETT |
| 1957-11-16 | Tranmere Rovers v Witton Albion | 2-1 | FAC 1 | 1957-58 | DUTHIE |
| 1957-11-09 | Witton Albion v Buxton | 2-2 | | 1957-58 | HACKETT, WAGSTAFFE |
| 1957-11-06 | Witton Albion v Norton Woodseats | 6-1 | FAC 4q Rep. | 1957-58 | HACKETT, HACKETT, ELSBY, WAGSTAFFE, TAPLEY (p), DALE |
| 1957-11-02 | Norton Woodseats v Witton Albion | 0-0 | FAC 4q. | 1957-58 | |
| 1957-10-26 | Witton Albion v Runcorn | 0-0 | | 1957-58 | |
| 1957-10-19 | Witton Albion v Altrincham | 3-2 | FAC 3q. | 1957-58 | HACKETT, HACKETT, DORSETT |
| 1957-10-12 | Witton Albion v Ellesmere Port Town | 1-1 | | 1957-58 | MELIA |
| 1957-10-05 | Witton Albion v Northwich Victoria | 3-2 | FAC 2q. | 1957-58 | HACKETT, DORSETT, DUTHIE |
| 1957-10-02 | Witton Albion v Buxton | 0-3 | CLC 2 | 1957-58 | |
| 1957-09-28 | Bangor City v Witton Albion | 3-1 | | 1957-58 | DORSETT |
| 1957-09-25 | Congleton Town v Witton Albion | 3-2 | | 1957-58 | DALE, DORSETT |
| 1957-09-21 | Witton Albion v Congleton Town | 4-0 | FAC 1q. | 1957-58 | HACKETT, DORSETT, ELSBY, WAGSTAFFE |
| 1957-09-18 | Witton Albion v Northwich Victoria | 5-3 | CLC 1 | 1957-58 | HACKETT, HACKETT, WAGSTAFFE, BARNES (p), TAPLEY (p) |
| 1957-09-14 | Witton Albion v Macclesfield Town | 3-2 | | 1957-58 | DUTHIE, DUTHIE, TAPLEY (p) |
| 1957-09-11 | Ellesmere Port Town v Witton Albion | 4-0 | | 1957-58 | |
| 1957-09-04 | Witton Albion v Mossley | 7-1 | | 1957-58 | DORSETT, DORSETT, DORSETT, DUTHIE, DUTHIE, ELSBY, Kelly (og) |
| 1957-08-31 | Runcorn v Witton Albion | 0-3 | | 1957-58 | TAPLEY, TAPLEY, ELSBY |
| 1957-08-27 | Mossley v Witton Albion | 1-2 | | 1957-58 | DORSETT, DUTHIE |
| 1957-08-24 | Witton Albion v Winsford United | 2-1 | | 1957-58 | McCANN, BARNES |
| 1957-05-03 | Runcorn v Witton Albion | 0-3 | NSC F. | 1956-57 | DUTHIE, DALE, BARNES (p) |
| 1957-05-01 | Witton Albion v Northwich Victoria | 3-1 | NSC S/F | 1956-57 | ELSBY, ELSBY, DALE |
| 1957-04-22 | Witton Albion v Stockport County Reserves | 3-2 | | 1956-57 | ELSBY, DALE, DUTHIE |
| 1957-04-20 | Witton Albion v Wellington Town | 1-1 | | 1956-57 | ELSBY |
| 1957-04-19 | Northwich Victoria v Witton Albion | 1-1 | | 1956-57 | ELSBY |
| 1957-04-13 | Winsford United v Witton Albion | 1-3 | NSC 1 | 1956-57 | ELSBY, ELSBY, Huddart (og) |
| 1957-04-10 | Witton Albion v Rhyl | 2-1 | | 1956-57 | ELSBY, PERRIN (p) |
| 1957-04-06 | Crewe Alexandra Reserves v Witton Albion | 0-1 | | 1956-57 | DORSETT |
| 1957-03-30 | Stalybridge Celtic v Witton Albion | 2-0 | | 1956-57 | |
| 1957-03-23 | Witton Albion v Stafford Rangers | 2-0 | | 1956-57 | ELSBY, BARNES (p) |
| 1957-03-20 | Witton Albion v Macclesfield Town | 3-2 | | 1956-57 | ELSBY, ELSBY, ELSBY |
| 1957-03-16 | Tranmere Rovers Reserves v Witton Albion | 1-3 | | 1956-57 | McCANN, ELSBY, BARNES (p) |
